Best: Overall

• Sensitivity level: Zero to minimal

Both the toothpaste and the strips in this kit contain hydrogen peroxide, aka the key to dazzling teeth. While it’s up to you how you balance the two products, we used both in tandem over the course of two weeks. The toothpaste works exactly how you’d expect it to and helps maintain the results of the strips, which need to be applied to dry teeth for an hour at a time. We admit that wearing strips for so long was irritating at first but more than worth the discomfort – these were the best we tried, giving us the beginnings of a glowing smile after two days without any sensitivity. After a full fortnight’s use, we barely recognised our smile.

Read the full Spotlight Oral Care teeth whitening system set review

Best: Whitening toothpaste

• Sensitivity level: Zero to minimal

Whitening toothpaste is the easiest way to treat your teeth as it slots into your daily routine without creating an additional step. Its consistency is more like a gel than your average toothpaste and, other than feeling slightly warm as you brush, works exactly the same and leaves your mouth minty fresh. 

Regenerate’s patented “NR-5” technology prides itself on recreating the mineral that makes up tooth enamel, which in turn reverses the erosion process and protects against cavities, acid and decay. The effects are a slow-burn – we didn’t realise our teeth were getting whiter until we compared two pictures two weeks apart – but the ease of use makes it worth the wait. As an added bonus: it also helped ease our tester’s notoriously sensitive teeth.

Read the full Regenerate enamel science advanced toothpaste review

Best: For removing deep-set stains

• Sensitivity level: Mild to medium

Deep-set stains are the hardest to remove so are best targeted with a more direct treatment. Enter blue light activation technology – combined with a whitening gel, it’s scientifically proven to whiten teeth without damaging enamel. It sounds complicated but this kit is super easy to use. Simply apply the pre-treatment spray first, coat the teeth tray in gel and plug it into any USB outlet or smartphone for 15 minutes at a time.

This kit is more generous than most, providing enough gel for 20 treatments. This was more than enough time to see results. About five days in, our tester noticed that the stubborn yellow on her canine teeth was much less noticeable than usual. Our only issue was the tray itself – depending on the shape of your bite, it’s slightly uncomfortable. However, at 15 minutes a day, it’s easy to grin and bear it.

Read the full Rio Smile white advanced teeth whitening kit review

Best: For dissolvable strips

• Sensitivity level: Mild to medium

Like any single-use product, whitening strips are useful yet wasteful. To fix this, Boots has designed these innovative dissolvable strips. They apply like any other strips, sitting for about 15 minutes before disintegrating. The taste was slightly more chemically than other strips, but not unbearable, and while they leave a hint of tackiness it’s nothing a quick dry brush can’t fix. Those looking for a quick fix might be disappointed – it took us two weeks to see even a gradual change. But thankfully the pack comes with 56 strips, giving you plenty of time to tackle discolouration.

Read the full Boots expert dissolvable teeth whitening strips review

Best: For all-natural teeth whitening

• Sensitivity level: Zero to minimal

Activated charcoal is an age-old beauty hack, doing everything from exfoliating your skin to clearing your pores. When using it to whiten your teeth, there’s an inevitable moment where you will doubt your sanity (applying a thick, dark powder to something you want to brighten feels extremely counterproductive) but trust us, it works. We recommend brushing this Kiki Health powder onto your teeth with a wet toothbrush for as long as you would toothpaste. Once done, rinse with warm water. It takes a couple of weeks to see a real difference, but one pot will keep you going for a while.

Read the full Kiki Health activated charcoal powder review

Best: For tea and coffee drinkers

• Sensitivity level: Zero to minimal

It’s tough to target discolouration caused by long-term consumption of coffee and tea, but White Glo is giving it a good shot. This toothpaste uses micro polishing particles to tackle yellowing on the enamel while also forming a protective shield against new stains. Like most whitening toothpaste, this requires some patience. It took over two weeks for our tester to notice a difference but our teeth only brightened from that point on. Unsurprisingly, stubborn stains took longer to lift.

Read the full White Glo coffee and tea drinkers formula review

Best: For targeting treatment on small stains

• Sensitivity level: Zero to minimal

Don’t let the mystical name put you off, this is all rooted in science. Each of the 14 wands are filled with liquid, with half targeting stains and the other half whitening. Used in that order, they work by rubbing over the surface of your teeth – sort of like a more precise toothbrush. The method didn’t seem rigorous enough to us at first but does the job. We especially liked how easy it was to spot treat more problematic areas, giving you a more even glow across your grin.

Read the full Smile Science Harley Street professional teeth whitening wands review

Best: LED teeth whitening

• Sensitivity level: Mild to medium

While most teeth whitening products require a minimum of 14 days of use, this kit promises results in less than half that time. Six doses of gel are applied over the teeth before putting on the mouth tray – which is attached to an LED light – for 15 minutes at a time. While there was no immediate difference, our teeth were brighter and whiter after four consecutive days of use. It didn’t quite live up to the higher end of the predicted results (a lucky few claim to see their teeth lighten by eight shades) but with additional courses of treatment, we think we could have definitely got there. Top-up doses of gel currently cost £17.99 and are as vegan-friendly as the main kit.

Read the full SmileTime teeth whitening kit review