Can you give me more details/specs when this menu item should be active and when not?

Sure. Essentially, the "Site" menu item should only be active when:

• You click "Appearance > Editor" (this works currently)
• You click the Site menu item itself (this also works)

In any other case the flow is template-centric (IE you are navigating through the Templates List), so it doesn't make sense to make the "Site" item active in those situations.

I appreciate this is a little tricky to pin down since template + site editing exist in the same package, but the split in the UX makes this feel quite important.

The problem is that we do a redirection upon clicking on the "Site" link. There's essentially no page which is called "Site", we immediately redirect the user to the template editor (which is the frontpage template by default). Should we:

• Highlight the "Site" link only when we're on the default(frontpage) template, or
• Highlight the "Site" link whenever we're editing any template but not template parts,
• Or anything else

Since we always do a full navigation, so we don't have the information of where we're coming from (whether we click on the "Site" link or not). Since this would likely be linked to the aria-current attribute in #36946, I guess it makes sense to have accessibility folks giving feedbacks on this as well. WDYT?

None of these options seem very good to me. It would be very strange imo to see "Site" as the active menu item when editing the Page template via the templates list (assuming a static home page it set in this example).

Probably a dumb question but... logic exists somewhere to interpret the homepage settings in order to display the correct template / content when opening the site editor. Can we not use that same logic to determine when to set the active state on the Site menu item?

I think we can check if page?.path === siteUrl. Currently, this is only true for the home/index page.

@Mamaduka would that same logic allow us to display the site name / url in the top bar when editing the homepage? (#36207)

Technically yes. I can create a proof of concept PR later this week.

Probably a dumb question but... logic exists somewhere to interpret the homepage settings in order to display the correct template / content when opening the site editor. Can we not use that same logic to determine when to set the active state on the Site menu item?

Isn't this the same as my first proposal? Or am I missing something 🤔 ?

Highlight the "Site" link only when we're on the default(frontpage) template

I don't think it's quite the same, but perhaps I am misinterpreting.

Highlight the "Site" link only when we're on the default(frontpage) template

In this case, if a static page were set as the front page, wouldn't this mean that the "Site" menu item would be active if you navigated to Templates > Page? That would be kind of confusing.